Is Dogecoin (DOGE) Still a Buy After Elon Musk's Departure From the DOGE Agency?

Dogecoin (CRYPTO: DOGE) has dropped sharply from its recent 52-week high, and although Elon Musk's departure from the DOGE agency might be grabbing headlines, it isn't the biggest reason. The meme token has struggled to find a use case in the real world, and if consumers, businesses, and investors don't have a tangible reason to own it, then it's impossible to create sustainable value.

According to Cryptwerk, just 2,096 businesses around the world accept Dogecoin as payment for goods and services. If consumers can't spend Dogecoin at their favorite stores, then they have no reason to buy it. Businesses probably won't warm up to the meme token anytime soon, because its extreme volatility would make cash-flow management a nightmare.

Dogecoin also has a supply issue. There are 149.5 billion tokens in circulation as of this writing, and although there is a cap on how many more can be "mined" each year, there is no end date. In other words, new tokens will enter the market until the end of time. I've never seen an investment-grade asset with an unlimited supply that rises in value over the long term.

A timeline of Musk's Dogecoin support

Between 2019 and 2021, Musk regularly shared Dogecoin-related memes on social media and participated in friendly banter with other enthusiasts. Investors started to think he had a plan to create real value for the meme token, and that speculation reached a fever pitch in the lead-up to his appearance on Saturday Night Live.

During the show on May 8, 2021, Musk participated in a Dogecoin-themed comedy skit, which ended with him calling the meme token a "hustle." But as the dust settled, investors began to realize that there were no plans to defraud anyone. Instead, Musk was simply highlighting the fact that he had no interest in creating value for Dogecoin.

After the show ended, Dogecoin peaked at $0.73 per token. It plunged over the next 12 months, losing more than 90% of its value by mid-2022. It stayed largely dormant during 2023 and for most of 2024, until the U.S. presidential election.

Musk threw his cash and his influence behind Donald Trump, who campaigned on a series of pro-crypto policies, and Dogecoin soared (along with most cryptocurrencies) when Trump eventually won the presidency. A short time later, Trump announced plans to appoint Musk to run an external government agency tasked with reducing America's national debt by slashing spending.

Musk named the agency the Department of Government Efficiency, or DOGE for short, which was a clear reference to his favorite cryptocurrency. But to this day, Dogecoin has played no actual role in the agency, so its post-election rally was purely speculative.

Dogecoin's recent 52-week high came at $0.47, which is lower than the 2021 peak of $0.73, suggesting that investors were less willing to buy into the hype this time around. But the meme token is now trading at just $0.19, and there could still be plenty of room to fall if history is any guide.

Dogecoin bottomed at around $0.06 in 2022, which might be the level to watch. It implies that there could be 68% downside from the current price, and with Musk now out of the White House and no improvements to the meme token's fundamentals, that might be the path of least resistance.

As a result, I think it might be time to abandon Dogecoin and run for the hills.