Economist and gold supporter Peter Schiff, who is a long-time vocal critic of Bitcoin, never misses a chance to criticize the digital asset even amid its increasing adoption and success. However, in a surprising turn of events that keeps resurfacing in crypto circles, Schiff previously claimed that Dogecoin, a meme coin born as a joke, was a “better” cryptocurrency than Bitcoin.

经济学家和黄金支持者彼得·希夫（Peter Schiff）是比特币的长期发声批评者，从未错过批评数字资产的机会，甚至在其不断增长的采用和成功中。但是，在令人惊讶的事件中，席夫（Schiff）以前声称，迪格币（Dogecoin）是一个笑话的模因硬币，比比特币（Bitcoin）是“更好”的加密货币。

A History Of Bitcoin Criticism

比特币批评的历史

Schiff’s disdain for Bitcoin is no secret. Frequently poking fun at the primary cryptocurrency, he calls it “fool’s gold” and predicts its eventual downfall in social media posts and interviews.

席夫对比特币的鄙视不是秘密。他经常在主要的加密货币上开玩笑，称其为“愚人的黄金”，并预测其在社交媒体帖子和访谈中的最终失败。

The economist maintains that Bitcoin is driven by speculation rather than use, has no intrinsic value, is too volatile to be a store of wealth, and he claims that the hype about Bitcoin is false and deceitful to new investors.

这位经济学家认为，比特币是由投机而不是使用的驱动，没有内在的价值，太波动了，无法成为财富的存储，他声称关于比特币的炒作是虚假的，对新投资者有欺骗。

Even as Bitcoin gains more institutional recognition, being spotted on company balance sheets and even granted legal tender status in nations like El Salvador, Schiff remains undeterred. He still maintains that gold is a better hedge against economic uncertainty and inflation than a “digital token invented out of thin air.”

即使比特币获得了更多的机构认可，被发现在公司资产负债表上，甚至在埃尔·萨尔瓦多（El Salvador）等国家授予法定招标地位，Schiff仍然没有被忽视。他仍然坚持认为，与“从稀薄的空气中发明的数字代币”相比，黄金是对经济不确定性和通货膨胀的更好的对冲。

The Dogecoin Contradiction

狗狗币矛盾

Ironically, Schiff appears to favor Dogecoin over Bitcoin in earlier remarks—not because he supports the principles of Dogecoin but rather as a way of parodying Bitcoin’s value proposition.

具有讽刺意味的是，席夫（Schiff）在早期的讲话中似乎比比特币（Bitcoin）更喜欢狗狗币（Dogecoin），而不是因为他支持狗狗币的原理，而是作为模仿比特币价值主张的一种方式。

During a heated argument on Twitter, Schiff stated that while both are speculative, Dogecoin is “a better crypto than Bitcoin,” pointing out that Dogecoin doesn’t claim to be digital gold.

在Twitter上的激烈争论中，Schiff表示，尽管两者都是投机性的，但Dogecoin“比比特币更好”，指出Dogecoin并不声称自己是数字黄金。

According to his argument, Dogecoin’s open stupidity made it less deceitful than Bitcoin, which he sees as attempting to pass for a real financial instrument.

根据他的论点，Dogecoin的开放性愚蠢使它没有比特币的欺骗性，他认为这是试图通过真正的金融工具。

While this was meant to be sarcastic, critics have not let go of this contradiction. Would Schiff cancel out Bitcoin as worthless? And how could a meme coin with an unlimited supply be deemed “better” in any sense?

尽管这本来是讽刺的，但批评家并没有放弃这种矛盾。 Schiff会消除比特币是毫无价值的吗？在任何意义上，如何将具有无限供应的模因硬币视为“更好”？

Is Schiff Ignoring The Bigger Picture?

希夫无视大局吗？

Schiff’s remarks highlight a broader misinterpretation, or deliberate dismissal, of how value derives in the crypto realm. Unlike gold, Bitcoin’s value stems from its scarcity, decentralization, and expanding network effect, not physicality.

希夫的言论突出了更广泛的误解或故意解雇价值在加密货币领域中的衍生方式。与黄金不同，比特币的价值源于其稀缺，权力下放和扩大的网络效应，而不是物理性。

It lacks the functional edge, with Dogecoin having no institutional support, global remittance use cases, and capability as a hedge in underdeveloped nations. While enjoyable and community-driven, Dogecoin is famously inflationary and has significantly fewer application cases.

它缺乏功能优势，而Dogecoin没有机构支持，全球汇款用例以及能力作为欠发达国家的树篱。 Dogecoin虽然令人愉悦且以社区为导向，但著名的通货膨胀率却大大减少。

Dogecoin survives on internet culture and celebrity endorsements, especially from figures like Elon Musk. Schiff’s attempt to juxtapose the two simply showcases a bias ingrained in ideology rather than the changing financial reality.

Dogecoin在互联网文化和名人代言上幸存下来，尤其是从埃隆·马斯克（Elon Musk）等人物中。席夫（Schiff）将两者并列的尝试只是展示了意识形态根深蒂固的偏见，而不是不断变化的财务现实。

The Market Remains Skeptical

市场仍然持怀疑态度

Although Peter Schiff is still among the most outspoken critics of Bitcoin, his contradictory stance praising Dogecoin to make a point has inadvertently undermined his credibility in the debate. While criticism is healthy, neglecting to acknowledge Bitcoin’s ongoing significance and expansion runs the risk of being out of touch.

尽管彼得·希夫（Peter Schiff）仍然是比特币最直言不讳的批评者之一，但他矛盾的立场称赞狗狗币提出的观点并无意中削弱了他在辩论中的信誉。虽然批评是健康的，但忽略承认比特币的持续意义和扩张却有失去联系的风险。

Whether Schiff will ever change his tune remains to be seen. However, even the most ardent critics may now have to revise their claims as Bitcoin continues to shape global financial systems.

席夫是否会改变他的曲调还有待观察。但是，随着比特币继续塑造全球金融体系，即使是最热心的批评家也可能不得不修改其主张。